Reading: les propines als Estats Units

Exercici 2 · PAU 2025, ordinària, sèrie 1 · 3 punts

Comprensió escrita amb preguntes obertesCobreix totes les idees de la pauta

2025Convocatòria ordinària · Sèrie 1 · Exercici 2Part 2: Reading comprehension, tipping in the United States

3 puntsCobreix totes les idees de la pauta

Torna al tema4 de 6

Després dels 6

Vols continuar amb el tema de comprensió escrita amb preguntes obertes?

Aquests 6 són els de la PAU del 2025 al 2026 que tenim resolts. A EducaIA continues amb exercicis, tests i flashcards del tema, a partir dels teus apunts o d’uns de base que et redacta.

Continua practicant

TIPPING IS MORE CONFUSING THAN EVER. HERE’S HOW TO HANDLE IT

Tipping has never been more confusing. Americans might always have disagreed on exactly how much to tip—20, 15, 10 percent?—but they generally knew where to do it. Now, tipping screens are popping up on iPads practically everywhere, and politicians are making things even harder by trying to adjust the laws around tipping.

[5] Americans have been leaving a little extra with the bill for pretty much as long as the country has existed. But the practice really only took off after the Civil War, when travelers abroad brought the custom home to pay formerly enslaved black people, many of whom worked for a pittance as porters for the Pullman Company. Eventually, when restaurants took off as an industry separate from hotels and boarding places, gratuity became popular there, too. [10] When minimum wage laws arrived with the New Deal, it made sense to legislators to exempt workers in professions where the expected tips would account for the difference. Similar thinking held when Congress created the “tip credit” system in the 1960s: allowing businesses to pay tipped personnel a subminimum wage only as long as tips brought their earnings to or above the minimum.

[15] From there, tipping culture perpetuated itself. Americans know restaurant workers or, to a lesser extent, carwashers and hairdressers, legally don’t take home enough money without tips, so the expectation that people will tip them has become customary. And as long as Americans keep tipping, the law can stay the same. Only recently, this status quo has become unstable. The laws started to change in the 2010s, when some cities, including D.C., and several states [20] decided to experiment with cancelling the tip credit. Meanwhile, Congress passed legislation in 2018 allowing restaurants that pay servers the statutory minimum to redistribute any tips those employees do receive to back-of-house staff. Norms have changed, too, in more recent years—but in the opposite direction. Seventy-two percent of Americans said in a 2023 survey that they believe tips are expected in more places. That’s thanks in part to the dawn of the digital [25] payment era: pressing “no” on an iPad tip screen feels a lot ruder than neglecting to toss a dollar in a glass jar.

There’s plenty of reasons to wish tipping would disappear altogether. People’s tips might depend on how they look rather than the quality of their service. The unpredictability of pay—a rainy night likely means a lighter wallet—means undue financial stress for the tipped [30] worker. Cooks and dishwashers also end up worse off than servers, especially at higher-end establishments, regardless of skill. On the other hand, research suggests the existence of tipping may yield better service, at least here in the United States. And many restaurants have struggled to support themselves without the flexibility the system allows them. In short, tipping probably isn’t going to disappear anytime soon, and something like the status quo is not necessarily bad.

[35] Where does that leave customers? One principle is simple: Where there’s a subminimum wage, tip. The second factor to consider is more complicated and more personal: tip when someone is doing you a service that’s worth more to you than the person serving you is getting for it. Maybe that is someone doing an average job in an above-average way—a locksmith who spends hours in the cold to let you in your house, or a barista with a flair for latte art. Or maybe [40] it’s someone doing unpleasant work for very little—hotel cleaning staff remedying a big mess. What kind of tipper are you?

Text adapted from an article by David Shipley. The Washington Post [online] (September 23, 2024)

pittance: misèria / miseria
toss: llençar / lanzar

QUESTIONS

Answer the questions below using complete sentences. You may use fragments from the text unless specified not to do so.

[3 points: 0.5 points for each correct answer. Up to 0.3 points might be deducted from the total mark for lack of intelligibility in the answers provided.]

2.1 When and how did the practice of tipping start in America?

[0.5 points]

2.2 Find a sentence in the text that corresponds to the following rewritten/paraphrased sentence: “Since the early days of the United States, people have routinely added a small bonus to their payments.”

[0.5 points]

2.3 Explain the tip credit system that was created in the 1960s IN YOUR OWN WORDS. You may use the words pay, minimum and businesses.

[0.5 points]

2.4 Why are tips believed to be expected in more places now?

[0.5 points]

2.5 Rewrite/paraphrase the sentence: “People’s tips might depend on how they look rather than the quality of their service” (lines 27-28). You may keep grammatical words (i.e. the, might, their, how, etc.) and the following words: tips, service.

[0.5 points]

2.6 Explain IN YOUR OWN WORDS the second factor customers should consider when deciding whether to tip or not.

[0.5 points]

Resposta model d’EducaIA

Escriu la teva resposta i compara-la amb la de la pauta: marca el que tenia la teva.

2.1 0,5 punts2.2 0,5 punts2.3 0,5 punts2.4 0,5 punts2.5 0,5 punts2.6 0,5 punts

Explicacions i respostes model d’EducaIA. La pauta oficial del 2025 i 2026 dona diverses formulacions vàlides de cada pregunta, no una resposta model única.

2.10,5 punts

Pregunta 2.1 a l’enunciat oficial, en anglès

When and how did the practice of tipping start in America?

La resposta model

Tipping spread after the Civil War, when Americans who had been abroad brought the habit home and used it to reward formerly enslaved Black workers, many of whom had badly paid jobs as Pullman porters.

El que puntua la pauta

0,5 punts. La pauta no reparteix idea per idea els punts del contingut d’aquest apartat.

Demana dues dades, quan i com, i la resposta les ha d’unir en una frase completa. Busca-les al segon paràgraf: quan es va estendre el costum («the practice really only took off after the Civil War») i qui el va portar i per a què. Pots copiar fragments del text.

La pauta accepta, en anglès i literal:

  • The practice of tipping started in America after the Civil War and it was brought by travellers who used to pay formerly enslaved black people, many of whom worked for a pittance as porters for the Pullman Company.

2.20,5 punts

Pregunta 2.2 a l’enunciat oficial, en anglès

Find a sentence in the text that corresponds to the following rewritten/paraphrased sentence: “Since the early days of the United States, people have routinely added a small bonus to their payments.”

La resposta model

Americans have been leaving a little extra with the bill for pretty much as long as the country has existed.

El que puntua la pauta

0,5 punts. La pauta no reparteix idea per idea els punts del contingut d’aquest apartat.

Es demana una frase del text, no una explicació: copia-la tal qual, sense canviar-la. Busca la que diu des de quan es deixa un extra amb el compte als Estats Units; és al començament del segon paràgraf, a les línies 5 i 6.

La pauta accepta, en anglès i literal:

  • Americans have been leaving a little extra with the bill for pretty much as long as the country has existed (lines 5-6).

2.30,5 punts

Pregunta 2.3 a l’enunciat oficial, en anglès

Explain the tip credit system that was created in the 1960s IN YOUR OWN WORDS. You may use the words pay, minimum and businesses.

La resposta model

Businesses could lawfully give tipped employees less than the minimum wage, on condition that gratuities raised the workers’ total pay to that level or beyond.

El que puntua la pauta

0,5 punts. La pauta no reparteix idea per idea els punts del contingut d’aquest apartat.

La pregunta demana les teves paraules: no copiïs frases del text com «allowing businesses to pay tipped personnel a subminimum wage». Pots fer servir les paraules pay, minimum i businesses. Has de dir dues coses: que es podia pagar menys del mínim a qui rep propines i amb quina condició.

La pauta accepta, en anglès i literal:

  • The tip credit system permitted businesses to pay their staff less than required if tipping increased their salaries to the minimum or more.

2.40,5 punts

Pregunta 2.4 a l’enunciat oficial, en anglès

Why are tips believed to be expected in more places now?

La resposta model

Because customers now pay on digital screens, declining a tip there seems far ruder than simply not putting any change in a jar.

El que puntua la pauta

0,5 punts. La pauta no reparteix idea per idea els punts del contingut d’aquest apartat.

La causa és al final del tercer paràgraf, a partir de «That’s thanks in part to the dawn of the digital payment era». La teva resposta ha de donar aquesta raó (el pagament digital) i pot explicar per què rebutjar la propina en una pantalla resulta incòmode. Pots copiar fragments del text.

La pauta accepta, en anglès i literal:

  • Tips are believed to be expected in more places because we are in the digital era and pressing “no” on a screen feels ruder than not leaving any dollars in a jar/neglecting to toss a dollar in a glass jar.

2.50,5 punts

Pregunta 2.5 a l’enunciat oficial, en anglès

Rewrite/paraphrase the sentence: “People’s tips might depend on how they look rather than the quality of their service” (lines 27-28). You may keep grammatical words (i.e. the, might, their, how, etc.) and the following words: tips, service.

La resposta model

The tips that customers leave may be based on a server’s appearance instead of the standard of the service.

El que puntua la pauta

0,5 punts. La pauta no reparteix idea per idea els punts del contingut d’aquest apartat.

És una paràfrasi: canvia les paraules i la construcció («how they look», «the quality of their service») i conserva el sentit: la propina pot dependre de l’aspecte de qui serveix i no del bé que serveix. Pots mantenir les paraules gramaticals i tips i service.

La pauta accepta, en anglès i literal:

  • The tips workers get/receive might be determined by/might be related to their appearance rather than/and not by/to how well they treat you/how good the service was. (among others)

2.60,5 punts

Pregunta 2.6 a l’enunciat oficial, en anglès

Explain IN YOUR OWN WORDS the second factor customers should consider when deciding whether to tip or not.

La resposta model

Customers should weigh up whether the service benefits them more than the pay that the person providing it receives.

El que puntua la pauta

0,5 punts. La pauta no reparteix idea per idea els punts del contingut d’aquest apartat.

Demana les teves paraules i el segon factor, no el primer: el primer és «Where there’s a subminimum wage, tip». El segon compara el que val per a tu el servei amb el que rep qui el presta. No copiïs la frase del text.

La pauta accepta, en anglès i literal:

  • The second factor we should consider when tipping is whether the service you receive/are provided with/get is better/of higher quality/more valuable than the money the person doing it is receiving.

Et faltava alguna idea de la resposta model?

La Ruta guiada d’EducaIA prepara el tema de comprensió escrita amb preguntes obertes així: lliçó a lliçó, sense passar de tema fins a dominar-lo.

Cada lliçó en practica dos, per torns:
  • Forats
  • Dictat
  • Drills
  • Glossari

Amb un compte gratuït. Hi arribes amb la matèria, el tema i la Ruta guiada triats, i no es crea res fins que ho confirmes.

Enunciat: Generalitat de Catalunya, Consell Interuniversitari de Catalunya, Oficina d’Accés a la Universitat. PAU d’Anglès 2025, convocatòria ordinària. La imatge és l’examen oficial tal qual i el text el reprodueix; les explicacions i les respostes model són d’EducaIA. Consultat el 7 de novembre de 2026; el document no declara data d’última actualització.

L’examen sencerExamen (PDF)Pauta de correcció (PDF)Reutilitzat segons l’avís legal de la Generalitat

PAU 2027 · Catalunya

El teu pla fins a la PAU d’Anglès

Des del 2025, l’examen ha preguntat 7 temes d’Anglès, i hi arribes amb tots posats (primer el d’aquest exercici i després els altres, del que més ha sortit al que menys) i amb la data en què comença la PAU ordinària: l’1 de juny de 2027. EducaIA te’ls reparteix per dies fins a l’examen i, amb els teus apunts o amb uns de base que et redacta, et prepara exercicis, tests i flashcards. Abans de crear el pla, ho canvies tot.

  1. Comprensió escrita amb preguntes obertes· aquest exercici6 de 6 exàmens
  2. Comprensió oral6 de 6 exàmens
  3. Ressenya, descripció, blog i altres textos4 de 6 exàmens
  4. Assaig d’opinió i argumentatiu3 de 6 exàmens
  5. Correu i carta formal2 de 6 exàmens
  6. Assaig a favor i en contra1 de 6 exàmens
  7. Narració1 de 6 exàmens

Cada xifra: en quants dels 6 exàmens del 2025 al 2026 que tenim resolts ha sortit algun exercici d’aquell tema. El 2025 va canviar l’examen: no hi compten els d’abans, ni hi van els temes que només sortien llavors. És el que ha passat, no una predicció. La data, del calendari oficial de la PAU 2027.

Amb un compte gratuït. Hi arribes amb els temes i la data posats, i no es crea res fins que ho confirmes.

Enunciat oficial

Toca la imatge per apropar-la o allunyar-la.